
In Marxist theory, the Lumpenproletariat (German: [ˈlʊmpn̩pʁoletaʁi̯ˌaːt] ⓘ; /ˌlʌmpənproʊlɪˈtɛəriət/) is the underclass devoid of class consciousness. Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels coined the word in the 1840s and used it to refer to the unthinking lower strata of society exploited by reactionary and counter-revolutionary forces[….]—from the Wikipedia entry for “Lumpenproletariat”
Dear American Lumpenproletariat,
It has recently come to my attention that the current mess we’re in is all my fault.
That is because I am evidently among the “elite.”
My membership in the “elite” came as a surprise to me. I don’t summer in Martha’s Vineyard and I have a hard time remembering which is Monet and which Manet. But still, I’m flattered. It’s cool to be called elite!
I’m elite, you tell me, because I have a college degree. I’m elite because I read the New York Times and watch the PBS Newshour. I’m Jewish, which gets me halfway to elite all by itself. I don’t live on a coast, but I do live in Austin, which is even worse. I use words like “lumpenproletariat.”
According to your prophets, Donald Trump has been inflicted on this country because of me, and people like me. For too long I ignored your concerns. I gave little kids autism by making them get vaccinated against measles and COVID. I freely let vicious drug terrorists into this country so they could take over your jobs cleaning restrooms and fixing roofs. I have blighted the American landscape with windmills and solar panels where once glorious American smokestacks belched giant plumes of 100% American coal smoke instead of relying on cheap imported sunshine, or wind that comes from God knows where.
Even worse, I allowed men who changed into girls to fight and die for their country, just like regular men. And I wouldn’t shut up about stuff like race and gender discrimination, which makes innocent white men feel guilty, or like they’re supposed to do something about it. And on, and on.
Boy, you really nailed me! I only wonder why you let me get away with it for so long! But you finally won. You must be so relieved!
Actually, I’m kind of relieved, too. I’m no longer responsible for defending the weak, healing the ill, seeking justice for the oppressed, protecting the planet from fire and flood, speaking truth to power. Because you’re in charge now. You won! You have the White House, the Department of Justice and all of the federal law enforcement agencies that go with it, and for the moment, both houses of Congress. And with Republican state legislatures apparently free to custom-make congressional districts every election cycle, you’re likely to be in control of that chamber…forever. And the Supreme Court? 3 of the 9 justices were appointed by Trump, 3 more by previous conservative presidents. There goes that last annoying check and balance!
And haven’t you been busy! Deporting day-laborers first, asking questions (or not) later. Renaming military bases back to generals who betrayed their country and slaughtered as many American troops as they could in defense of slavery. Firing scholars and scientists and yanking funds for cancer research. Opening investigations on anyone who so much as hinted that maybe Donald Trump is a poopy head. Must I go on?
You won! You should be so happy! But I don’t see a lot of happiness. More like continued anger and anxiety about the Deep State. Why is that, since…you now are the deep state?
You got all three branches of government. Your man is now commander-in-chief of the mighty armed forces of the United States of America. Big business? The grotesquely wealthy tech magnates are almost all on your side. Coca-Cola turned on a dime when Trump mused aloud about corn syrup vs. cane sugar. Mainstream media? They have mostly caved, from The Washington Post to CBS. And anyway, no one reads The Washington Post or watches “60 Minutes” anymore. There’s no deep state left…except for yours.
The intelligentsia? You’ve got them running scared, scrambling to wipe out any trace of “woke” and “diversity” and “critical race theory” at our colleges and universities. And anyway, who cares about them? To paraphrase Stalin, how many divisions does the intelligentsia command?
So my question for you is…now what?
I predict you’re going to be sicker than ever before, given cuts to Medicaid, reduced support for vaccines, reduced environmental regulation, less medical research, and an ever-hotter planet. RFK Jr. suggests you walk more. Prayer is also fine.
I predict you’ll be poorer, what with inflation and tariffs. And with the Trump tax cuts made permanent, the federal budget deficit will continue to grow explosively. Who knows when that bubble is going to burst?
I predict you’ll be dumber, particularly with respect to your own history and culture, given the elimination of a scholarly treatment of those subjects in our public schools and museums, and less support for public education, period.
I predict you’ll be less free than before, when you find out the hard way that if you start to complain too loudly, the police forces of our nation can be turned in your direction, too.
Oh well. You’ll always have duck hunting and golf.
I’m not worried about the future. It’s going to hurt everyone, but it’s going to hurt you a lot worse than me. I’m elite. And I’m not worried, because I can’t do anything about it, except to say what I think, which I already am. Beyond that, this country, and your future in it, are your problems now.
What are you going to do about it?
And if it seems like I’m dripping with condescension, it’s because…I am. I’m elite, baby…Dig it!








